|
|
||||||||
| ABSTRACT |
|
|
|---|
| INTRODUCTION |
|
|
|---|
The age-specific pattern of malaria morbidity and mortality reflects cumulative exposure, with populations subject to more intense transmission acquiring immunity at an earlier age.1,5 Malaria incidence studies were therefore carried out in two areas that differ in the intensity of transmission: a highland area with low and unstable transmission and a holoendemic area with intense year-round transmission.
| MATERIALS AND METHODS |
|
|
|---|
|
Low endemic highland study area. The second group of schools was located in Nandi District in the cooler and wetter Kenyan highlands, which experiences low and unstable seasonal transmission. Rainfall averages 2,428 mm per year. Average minimum and maximum temperatures are 12.2°C and 23.6°C (Kaimosi tea estate meteorologic station adjacent to the schools, unpublished data). Malaria transmission is acutely seasonal with most cases occurring during MayJuly after the peak rainfall, although the extent of the malaria burden varies considerably year to year.8 The area is prone to epidemics, with the most recent epidemic occurring in JuneJuly 2002, during the period of this study.9
The population of the area consists of indigenous Kalenjin people and Luhya settlers who have come from the lower malaria-endemic parts of western Kenya during the past 30 years. The economy is primarily rural subsistence agriculture, with some families growing tea as a cash crop. Other economic opportunities include casual labor on local tea estates. Schools within the catchment area of the Kapkangani Government Health Center (0.19°N, 34.98°E) were identified and classified according to ethnic mix. To minimize the effect of differential immunity, host genetic heterogeneity, and/or travel to malaria-endemic areas on the risk of malaria, only schools where almost all pupils were of indigenous Kalenjin descent were eligible for inclusion in the study. The three schools closest to the health center that fulfilled the ethnicity criteria were selected. These schools were located on the Nandi Escarpment and the elevation of the pupils homes varied considerably within schools. The altitude range of each schools catchment population was similar, but was greatest for Kiborgok school (range = 1,6812,056 meters), where some pupils lived at higher elevations than those attending Koibem or Kabaskei school, and where the elevation of pupils homes ranged between 1,713 and 1,885 meters and 1,739 and 1,830 meters, respectively.
Malaria surveillance. The incidence of malaria among children in standards 37 (typically 814 years old) was monitored prospectively over an 11-week period in MayJuly 2002, which corresponded to the time of peak malaria transmission in both study areas. A series of meetings were held with teachers, parents, and community leaders to explain the purpose and methodology of the study, that participation was voluntary, and that children were able to withdraw from the study at any time. Written parental consent was obtained for all children prior to enrollment. Three children were not enrolled due to parental refusal. Ethical approval was obtained from the Ethical Review Board of Kenyatta National Hospital, Nairobi and the Danish Central Ethical Committee.
Data were collected through a system of active case detection at the seven schools, supplemented by continuous passive case detection at the local government health unit. Each school was visited by the surveillance team (nurse, laboratory technician, and field assistant) 23 times per week to identify children with clinical episodes of malaria. To maximize case detection, class teachers identified and recorded the names of any children who were ill or absent from school each morning. Any child reporting fever or other malaria-related symptoms, or absenteeism due to illness was notified to the surveillance team for follow-up and screening either in school or at home. Absentees were visited at home. A morbidity questionnaire was completed and included age, sex, history and duration of fever, other presenting signs and symptoms, and whether the child had taken antimalarials in the previous week. A finger prick blood sample was taken from children who satisfied the following screening criteria: 1) one or more of the following symptoms suggestive of malaria within the previous 24 hours: fever, chills/shivering, rigors, vomiting, malaise, or generalized body pain, or 2) a demonstrable axillary temperature
37.5°C. Giemsa-stained thick and thin blood films were prepared and the number of asexual parasites counted against 200 leukocytes and expressed as parasites/microliter, assuming a white blood cell count of 8,000/µL. Hemoglobin levels were measured using a portable HemoCue photometer (HemoCue, Angelhom, Sweden). School children with clinically diagnosed episodes were treated with a standard dose of sulfadoxine-pyrimethamine on the day of survey. Other conditions requiring treatment were referred to the health unit.
The active surveillance in schools was supplemented by continuous passive case surveillance at Kapkangani Health Center and Bondo District Hospital. To minimize obstacles to seeking treatment, diagnosis and treatment at the local health unit were provided free of charge for school children enrolled in the study. At the end of the surveillance period, a cross-sectional survey among all school children was conducted to assess anthropometric status and the prevalence of helminth infections. Stool samples were examined for Schistosoma mansoni and intestinal nematodes using the Kato-Katz method. Weight was measured to the nearest 0.1 kg on a Soehnle electronic balance (Leicester, United Kingdom) with children wearing minimum clothing. Height was measured to the nearest 0.1 cm using a portable fixed-base stadiometer. Age was derived from the date of birth recorded in the school register. Height-for-age and weight-for-age of each child were expressed as differences from the median National Center for Health Statistics (NCHS) (Hyattsville, MD) reference values in z-scores.10 A child was classified as stunted or underweight if his or her z-score of height-for-age and weight-for-age, respectively, was in excess of 2 SD below the NCHS median.
Household mapping and household surveys in the highlands. Since some heterogeneity in transmission risk was anticipated within the highland study area, the homes of every schoolchild who had been enrolled in the study were visited and mapped.11 The location and elevation of homes were determined using a hand-held differential global positioning system with a positional and vertical accuracy within five meters.
Statistical analysis.
Person-years analysis was carried out to determine the incidence density of episodes of clinical attacks. An episode of malaria was defined as a child with one or more of the screening symptoms and a parasite density threshold
500 parasites/µL of blood, which was previously shown to be appropriate for children 1014 years old in a holoendemic area of western Kenya.12 Episodes in the same child occurring more than 28 days apart were regarded as repeat attacks. Four episodes, that occurred between 21 and 28 days after the first episode, were classified as late treatment failures and excluded from analysis.
For each child, the period under surveillance was determined from the class register of attendance kept by teachers. Any child absent from school for a period of 10 or more consecutive days was censored during the period of absence. Similarly, any child known to have received medical attention from any source other than the survey team, including any public or private health care provider, was censored for a period of 28 days (31 children in Nandi and 4 in Bondo). Twelve children, eight who were persistently absent and four who were treated privately on more than one occasion, were removed from the dataset.
The standard World Health Organization cut-off value of 120 g/L for defining anemia in children 1214 years old was corrected for the lower mean hemoglobin seen in populations of African extraction (10 g/L) and height above sea level.13 Due to the altitude difference, anemia was defined differently in the two study areas: a cut-off of 112 g/L was applied in Bondo and a cut-off of 116 g/L was applied in Nandi. No adjustment was made for variation with age and sex. Data were analyzed using Epi-Info version 6.04d (Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Atlanta, GA) and Excel® 2002 (SP1) (Microsoft, Redmond, WA). A chi-square test or Fishers exact test (as appropriate) were used to assess differences in proportions. Continuous data were analyzed using Students t-test. A logarithmic transformation was applied to normalize parasite counts, and the geometric mean parasite density was compared. Incidence rates were compared using a trend test for rates.14
| RESULTS |
|
|
|---|
|
500 parasites/µL, indicating a high probability that their symptoms are attributable to malaria infection was 146 (44% of those screened) in Nandi and 38 (14%) in Bondo. Hemoglobin levels were higher in Nandi than in Bondo (Mean hemoglobin level = 130 g/L and 122 g/L, respectively; t = 5.78, P < 0.001), which was slightly in excess of the 45 g/L difference that would be expected due to the differing altitude between the two areas. Similarly, the proportion of school children classified as anemic was slightly higher in Bondo than in Nandi: 25% of the 255 children in Bondo whose hemoglobin was assessed had a hemoglobin level < 112 g/L compared with 19% of 298 children in Nandi with a hemoglobin concentration < 116 g/L. This difference was not statistically significant (
2 = 3.22, P = 0.073).
Signs and symptoms.
The most common symptoms reported by the 184 school children with a clinical attack of malaria (as defined earlier) in the 24 hours before examination were headache (88%), chills (31%), fever (17%), malaise/body weakness (14%), vomiting (11%), generalized body pain (11%), abdominal pain (11%), and cough (7%). In contrast to the low rate of self-reported fever, more than half the children were febrile on the day of screening (54% with an axillary temperature
37.5°C), indicating that fever is not readily perceived by school children. Twenty-two percent of the cases were anemic, and one case had a hemoglobin level < 70 g/L. None of the cases died.
A raised body temperature was the most useful diagnostic indicator in both study areas, with a greater proportion of cases being febrile than non-cases (Table 2
). Cases in Nandi were also more likely to report chills and/or vomiting in the last 24 hours, but these were non-specific signs in Bondo. Headache, malaise, and abdominal pain were as commonly reported among cases as among non-cases in both areas. Malaria was more clearly associated with anemia in Nandi, with the mean hemoglobin level being significantly lower among cases than among non-cases, and with 23% of the cases being anemic compared with 16% of the non-cases. The mean hemoglobin level did not differ between cases and non-cases in Bondo.
|
2 = 116.79, degrees of freedom [df] = 1, P < 0.001). If all children with a positive blood film are classified as a malaria case, the incidence seen in Nandi increases slightly to 0.031 clinical attacks/child-week. This pattern was mirrored in the parasite density among slide-positive children (Figure 3
|
|
2 for trend = 30.87, df = 1, P < 0.001) (Figure 4
1,850 meters: 0.009 compared with 0.048 clinical attacks/ child-week, respectively (relative risk = 5.1, 95% CI = 2.510.2).
|
| DISCUSSION |
|
|
|---|
In contrast, the lower incidence of malaria in the holoendemic lowland schools is compatible with repeated exposure to malaria parasites in early life leading ultimately to the ability to limit parasite growth, such that by the time a child starts school, episodes of clinical malaria have usually become both less common and less severe. We cannot exclude the possibility that genetic differences between the two populations also play a role because this was not examined in the study. Prior use of antimalarials could affect both observed disease incidence and parasite density, but although more children in holoendemic schools reported having taken an antimalarial drug prior to screening compared with children in highland schools, this is not sufficient to account for a six-fold difference in incidence. It is also questionable whether the drugs and dose administered would be sufficient to achieve clinical cure.16 The case definition used incorporated a parasite density cut-off that was found to be appropriate among school children living in holoendemic areas,12 and may be less valid for a non-immune population in whom infection is more likely to result in symptomatic illness. However, in highland schools the estimates of incidence were similar irrespective of whether a parasite density cut-off was used or not, due to the high parasite densities seen in children with symptoms. It was thus possible to apply a single case definition for this age group, irrespective of local transmission intensity.
The patterns in hemoglobin level seen in the two study areas may in part reflect the differing pathologic mechanisms that give rise to anemia in parasitemic children.17 In Nandi, clinical attacks of malaria were clearly associated with lower hemoglobin levels, suggesting that uncontrolled parasite growth and increased erythrocyte destruction in a non-immune subject results in acute anemia. The high parasite densities among cases support this. Increased erythrocyte destruction may continue up to two weeks post-infection,18 and the full extent of acute malaria-related anemia in the highlands may be underestimated in our dataset. In Bondo, parasite densities were lower and clinical episodes of malaria were not associated with reduced hemoglobin levels. Nonetheless, chronic, low-level, asymptomatic infection with malarial parasites may have contributed to decreased hemoglobin levels in this semi-immune population. Other environmental and genetic differences between the two study areas may also play a role, such as the higher prevalence of hookworm in Bondo than in Nandi.
Ethnographic investigations showed that local perceptions of malaria differed between highland and lowland schools,19 and were consistent with the differing epidemiology of malaria in the two areas. In the Nandi highlands, malaria was seen as a life-threatening illness, and all those interviewed knew of school children who had died of malaria. There was a distinct local term for malaria (cheptigonit) and specific local herbal medicines. In contrast, in Bondo, malaria was seen as a mild "everyday illness" that was not clearly distinguished from other common illnesses. Nevertheless, malaria was ranked as the most common health problem among school children in both areas.
The observed incidence of clinical attacks in Bondo is similar to other previously reported rates for school age children living in holoendemic areas (Table 3
). While the age range and methods of case detection differ between studies, the empirical estimates are surprisingly consistent. In the majority of studies undertaken in areas with intense, perennial transmission, the annual malaria incidence was typically about 2025 cases/100 children per year. Two studies observed higher incidence rates. We could not identify any substantive methodologic difference between these and the other studies, although some variation in point estimates can be expected as a result of the inter-annual and seasonal fluctuations that typify malaria transmission. In comparison, in all areas of low endemicity, the annual incidence of clinical attacks exceeded 34 cases/100 children per year. In unstable areas, this can rise to 82 cases/100 child-years during an epidemic (as recorded in our study). Although the case definitions used did not always exclude children with low-density parasitemias (whose symptoms can be attributed to malaria with less certainty), it seems reasonable to conclude that school age children living in areas of low transmission experience as many, if not more, clinical attacks per year than children who are exposed to intense perennial transmission.
|
1,850 meters. Multivariate analysis including other environmental, household and individual-level factors confirmed altitude of childs home to be the most important risk factor in our highland study population.11 Spatial heterogeneity was also observed in Dakar, Senegal, where malaria incidence ranged from 27 to 109 per 100 school children per year according to distance of the childs home from mosquito breeding sites.20 Similar micro-variation over short distances has also been reported in other low-transmission settings.21,22 In summary, the data reported here, taken together with other published studies, indicate that the risk of malaria morbidity among school age children increases as transmission intensity decreases. The higher malaria burden seen among school children in low-transmission settings presumably reflects host differences in prior exposure and delayed acquisition of immunity. Within populations with little or no acquired immunity, infection is more likely to result in symptomatic illness, and incidence rates are positively associated with an increased probability of exposure.
In stable transmission areas, where clinical attacks are mild and infrequent, the impact of malaria among semi-immune school children is primarily indirect. Anemia resulting from persistent parasitemia may affect concentration and performance, although the impact is thought to be minimal compared with iron-deficiency anemia.2 In contrast, in areas of low or unstable transmission, malaria exerts direct, as well as indirect, effects. Among school children with little immunity, Plasmodium infections are more likely to result in symptomatic illness and, as our data indicate, clinical attacks are also associated with more anemia. Having used a system of active case detection and treatment, we were unable to investigate other aspects of malaria among school children, such as absenteeism, the incidence of severe malaria, or access to treatment under normal circumstances. Other studies suggest that malaria can account for up to 8% of school absenteeism,23 while in areas of low and unstable transmission epidemics can dramatically affect school attendance.15 Cerebral malaria is a more common complication in older children,24,25 and may be of particular concern among non-immune school children who remain vulnerable to clinical attacks of malaria at older ages. Cerebral malaria is associated with a high case-fatality rate, and it is estimated that 520% of those who survive will have gross neurologic sequelae.2 Whether the impact in older individuals at a later stage of neurologic development is similar is unclear. Few studies have documented the burden of malaria in older children and adults,26 and the incidence and long-term sequelae of cerebral complications among older age groups particularly warrants study.
Through impaired schooling and educational attainment, malaria ultimately impacts on human capital and economic development of populations living in malarious areas.27 Schools offer a potential delivery mechanism for interventions to improve prompt and effective treatment of malaria.4,28 A variety of approaches may be possible. First, teachers and pupils need to be equipped with accurate knowledge of appropriate treatment practices through educational materials and training that aim at improving recognition of symptoms and treatment practices, as well as disease prevention and health promotion.19 The provision of active control measures in schools, such as intermittent preventive treatment or engaging teachers in routine diagnosis and treatment of pupils can also potentially lessen the impact of malaria. Improving diagnosis and treatment is particularly important in areas of low and unstable transmission where the incidence of clinical attacks in school children is greatest. During epidemics, teachers can also be trained to serve as drug distributors for all age groups in the community (Abeku T, unpublished data). In holoendemic areas, strategies such as intermittent preventive treatment to lessen malaria-associated anemia, integrated into broader school health programs, may be most appropriate.
Received February 14, 2004. Accepted for publication July 7, 2004.
Acknowledgments: We are very grateful to the children and teachers of the schools in Kapkangani and Bondo who kindly participated in the study. We are also most appreciative of those who were responsible for carrying out the active and passive case detection, which made this analysis possible, and the fieldworkers who contributed towards data collection. We are grateful for the excellent work of the late Benbolt Mugo. We also thank Larry Barat, Tarekegn Abeku, and Brian Greenwood for their contributions and suggestions.
Financial support: This work was supported by the Danish Bilharziasis Laboratory, the World Bank, the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation (through an award to the Gates Malaria Partnership, London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine), and the Wellcome Trust (through a Prize Fellowship [062692] to Simon Brooker at the time of the study).
Authors addresses: Siân E. Clarke and Simon Brooker, Department of Infectious and Tropical Diseases, London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine, Keppel Street, London WC1E 7HT, United Kingdom, E-mails: sian.clarke{at}lshtm.ac.uk and simon.brooker{at}lshtm.ac.uk. Joseph Kiambo Njagi, Division of Malaria Control, and Division of Vector Borne Disease, Ministry of Health, Nairobi, Kenya, E-mail: eanmat{at}africaonline.co.ke. Eliud Njau and Eric Muchiri, Division of Vector Borne Disease, Ministry of Health, Nairobi, Kenya, E-mail: dvbd{at}wanachi.co.ke. Benson Estambale, Kenyatta National Hospital, PO Box 20723, Nairobi, Kenya, E-mail: bestambale{at}uonbi.ac.ke. Pascal Magnussen, Danish Bilharziasis Laboratory, Charlottenlund, Denmark, E-mail: pm{at}bilharziasis.dk.
| REFERENCES |
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
D. FERNANDO, D. DE SILVA, R. CARTER, K. N. MENDIS, and R. WICKREMASINGHE A RANDOMIZED, DOUBLE-BLIND, PLACEBO-CONTROLLED, CLINICAL TRIAL OF THE IMPACT OF MALARIA PREVENTION ON THE EDUCATIONAL ATTAINMENT OF SCHOOL CHILDREN. Am J Trop Med Hyg, March 1, 2006; 74(3): 386 - 393. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |