On the Protective Power of Yellow Fever Sera and Dengue Sera against Yellow Fever Virus
E. P. Snijders,
S. Postmus AND
W. Schüffner
From the Institute of Tropical Hygiene, Royal Colonial Institute at Amsterdam
1. The working hypothesis that under special conditions denguemight provoke a certain immunity to yellow fever is discussed.This hypothesis is considered to be as yet unproved. The knownfacts, in any event, testify against a humoral immunity.
2.A more sensitive adjustment was devised in Theiler's as wellas in Sawyer's mouse-protection test in order to avoid the riskof missing moderate and lower degrees of immunity. The modificationsapplied to the technique are described (in Theiler's test a1 in 10,000 filtered brain-emulsion was used; in Sawyer's acentrifuged emulsion of about 2.5 per cent concentration).
3.As a control for the technique, 5 sera of former yellow feverpatients were examined. By Theiler's method a distinct protectioncould be demonstrated in all cases; by Sawyer's method protectionwas evident in 3 cases (in 1 case the test was not applied,in the other it failed, repetition not being possible).
4.The examination of the sera of 5 assistants working moreorless regularly in the yellow fever laboratory revealed aweakprotective action in 2 of them, both by Theiler's method(emulsion,1 in 10,000) and by the modification of Sawyer'stest. Consideringthat these two individuals were the personswho had come intothe most intimate contact with the yellowfever material, itis believed that they must have had mild(abortive) attacksof yellow fever at some time in the past.
5. The sera of 20volunteers, who had been experimentally inoculatedwith virusof Sumatran and Javanese dengue, were tested by bothmethods;in several instances the tests were repeated. Despitethe sensitiveadjustment of the tests, a protective action againstyellowfever virus could not be demonstrated.
6. The immunity indengue and in yellow fever are compared,and the remarkabledifferences pointed out. In dengue the immunityshows considerableindividual variation with regard to intensityand duration,and specific antibodies cannot be demonstratedin the serum.In yellow fever the immunity is almost absoluteand antibodiesare almost always present in the serum in highconcentration.